Papa Kelsey's

I've been eating Papa Kelsey's for probably 30 years! There used to be a Jerome location a long time ago, which is where we would go after school. I've tried almost everything on the menu at some point and never been dissatisfied. When I was a kid I'd get the pizza sub. The pepperoni, cheese, and the bread they use is just the right texture. A half is about the size you'd get at some other sandwich shops, a whole is really great for two meals. Most recently I got the southwest chipotle chicken (there's a steak option that's amazing as well) and the chicken is tender and moist, the peppers and sauce are a perfect combo. I'm making myself hungry again. The hot turkey! Oh that one is so good! Seriously, just check it out for yourself. I can't imagine you'd be disappointed.

The food was amazing! The sandwich may not look good, but it was crisp on the outside and soft on the inside The flavor was really good too! They brought the food to our table. Amazing service! The cinnamon rolls are HUGE! This was my 1st time here. You need to eat here!

Amazing food! The Italian sub is the best sandwich I have had from any restaurant! It smells so good as you walk in with fresh dough and bread baking. This is a must try. I will return when I am back in town.

I started off by saying I wasn't a fan of subs and ate my words with the most delicious sub I've ever had! Definitely a must stop when visiting my family and the cinnamon roll!! It's a must! Super friendly staff!

Friendly owner working the front counter. Helpful with suggestions on what to order. Generous portions that tasted great! Definitely recommend. Thank you for lunch and conversation!

The husband I went here for the first time for lunch. The food wasnt bad, I got the chicken bacon ranch sub and the hubs got the pizza sub. Meals come with a drink and a bag of lays. We also got fries to share. Overall everything was fine. It was a little on the pricey side.

The food here at Papa Kelsey’s is really good and the atmosphere makes it the kind of place where you want to dine in. Also as a doordasher, I usually get good service and decent speed here, of course understanding that this isn’t a fast food restaurant.

I went to pick up my door dash order I went to the counter said the name on the order and spelled it and they said give us a minute the order was placed 45 mins prior and I was messaged that it was ready. My mother then went in and did the same thing it was magically ready and they apologized for the order mix-up.